Jim Knowles Leaves Ohio State for Penn State: A Stunning Move With Major Implications
COLUMBUS, Ohio — In a move that has sent shockwaves through the college football world, Jim Knowles, the architect of Ohio State’s dominant national championship-winning defense, is heading to Penn State for the same position. While many consider Ohio State the superior job, Knowles’ Pennsylvania roots may have played a key role in his decision to return home. Regardless of the reasoning, his departure is a massive shift in the Big Ten landscape, with Ohio State replacing him with former New England Patriots defensive coordinator and Detroit Lions head coach Matt Patricia.
Jim Knowles: One of the Best Defensive Minds in the Country
Knowles has earned a reputation as one of the premier defensive coordinators in college football, if not the best. Before arriving at Ohio State, he transformed Oklahoma State’s defense into one of the most formidable units in the nation. Under his leadership, the Cowboys ranked among the best despite not having the luxury of four- or five-star recruits. His success earned him a Broyles Award finalist nod, solidifying his standing as an elite defensive mind.
At Ohio State, Knowles dramatically transformed the Buckeyes’ defense. When he took over in 2022, the unit was ranked No. 38 in the country. In his first season, he improved it to No. 24. By his second season, Ohio State’s defense surged to No. 2 nationally, and in his third year, the Buckeyes became the No. 1 defense in the country. His ability to develop talent, scheme effectively, and create a disciplined, hard-hitting defense played a crucial role in Ohio State’s national championship run this past season. His departure leaves a significant void, as the Buckeyes must now adjust without the man who rebuilt their defensive identity.
Why Would Knowles Leave Ohio State for Penn State?
On paper, Ohio State is the better job. The Buckeyes have greater resources, consistently pull in top-tier recruiting classes, and are perennial national title contenders. Penn State, while a respected program, has struggled to break through as a true national power under James Franklin.
However, Knowles is a Pennsylvania native, and sometimes, the pull of home is strong. Whether it was purely a personal decision or if there were deeper football-related motivations, his move gives Penn State a massive boost while creating a major transition for Ohio State’s defense.
Ohio State’s Replacement: Matt Patricia Steps In
To replace Knowles, Ohio State has turned to Patricia, a name well known in the football world but more associated with the NFL than college football. Patricia served as the Patriots’ defensive coordinator from 2012 to 2017, winning two Super Bowls in three appearances under Bill Belichick.
In his first two seasons as New England’s defensive coordinator, the Patriots’ defense allowed an average of over 20 points per game. However, starting in 2014, Patricia orchestrated a major overhaul in the secondary, bringing in Darrelle Revis and Brandon Browner. That move played a key role in the Patriots’ Super Bowl XLIX victory over the Seattle Seahawks.
Patricia’s defenses continued to improve, allowing fewer than 20 points per game every season from 2014 to 2017. Heading into the 2016 season, Patricia elevated New England’s defense to the No. 1 ranking in the NFL, allowing just 15.6 points per game. That defensive dominance helped the Patriots win Super Bowl LI over the Atlanta Falcons in their historic 28-3 comeback. The following season, New England’s defense ranked No. 5, allowing 18.5 points per game and helping the Patriots reach Super Bowl LII. However, injuries on the defensive side played a factor in their loss to the Philadelphia Eagles.
After his tenure in New England, Patricia became the head coach of the Detroit Lions, though his time there was largely unsuccessful. He later returned to an off-field advisory role with the Patriots before joining the Philadelphia Eagles’ staff in 2023. After taking a year away from coaching in 2024, he is now set to return to the sidelines as Ohio State’s defensive coordinator.
Can Patricia Keep Ohio State’s Defense at an Elite Level?
Patricia’s track record in the NFL suggests he understands high-level defensive strategy, but the college game presents different challenges. Recruiting, player development, and adapting to the ever-changing offenses in the Big Ten will test his ability to succeed at Ohio State.
Ohio State fans will be eager to see whether Patricia can continue the dominance that Knowles established. His experience with elite talent in the NFL is a plus, but it remains to be seen if his defensive philosophies translate smoothly to college football.
The Big Ten Just Got More Interesting
Knowles heading to Penn State and Patricia stepping into the Ohio State defensive coordinator role adds another layer of intrigue to the Big Ten. The Buckeyes will be looking to maintain their status as the conference’s top program, while Penn State hopes that adding Knowles will help them take the next step toward becoming a true championship contender.
As the 2025 season approaches, all eyes will be on how these coaching moves impact two of the Big Ten’s biggest programs. Ohio State and Penn State’s defensive identities are shifting, and the ripple effects could be felt throughout college football.
Pacific Playbook 
Leave a comment